On Air Now
Early Breakfast with Lucy Coward 4am - 6am
25 July 2022, 18:02
The Canadian train company’s poster has caused havoc online as musicians try to decipher its time signature.
Complex time signatures have long been a point of frustration for many a musician. Let’s face it, no one enjoys trying to count to 11 each bar, let alone complicated cross-rhythms.
But a Canadian train company’s new marketing campaign has taken time signatures to a whole new level, and the online reaction has derailed the campaign’s message.
Metrolinx, which covers the Toronto and Hamilton area in Canada, has displayed posters in train stations publicising its new ticket offers, with a weekend day pass costing $10, or $15 for a two-day pass.
Someone needs to have a chat with Betty from marketing.... pic.twitter.com/W6l2BNcFKW— Helena Dix (@HelenaDix) July 21, 2022
Sounds great, right?
With the marketing slogan, ‘Don’t miss a beat this weekend’, one witty graphic designer has transformed the detail into a musical score. Except, it’s backfired rather extraordinarily.
Metrolinx has combined its ticket prices to create the brain-melting time signature of 10/15. For the mathematically minded, a ‘15th-note’ would be equivalent to a dotted semi-quaver-and-a-bit (good luck counting that).
To add to the madness, the music that follows the time signature (and an oddly placed bar line) manages to not only ‘not miss a beat’, but actually exceeds the length of a bar. By our estimations, one bar of music in 10/15 would be equivalent to a little over five quavers, or a minim and a quaver (and a bit more).
Instead, there are seven here… you do the maths.
Quite understandably, the mishap has whipped up a frenzy with musicians and mathematicians online attempting to decipher the passage. Among the suggestions is an alternative, more playable passage that would stay true to the time signature:
Or perhaps Metrolinx could adjust its ticket prices for the sake of the time signature, as another user advised.
The meter could be in 3, in which case we are missing one sixteenth note… but if we broaden the two we have, it may possibly work out 💪 I spent way too much time on this! They should have made the tickets $12 and $16…— Judith Ingolfsson (@jingolfsson) July 22, 2022
We particularly look forward to hearing the live version at Birmingham’s Symphony Hall, soon...