The 'scary spotlight' on music stars amid Kneecap terror charge

22 May 2025, 23:58 | Updated: 23 May 2025, 10:59

Before the amps are even switched on in Brockwell Park, there's been a lot of noise about who should or shouldn't be performing.

It's where Irish hip-hop trio Kneecap are set to play their first major show since band member Mo Chara was charged for allegedly displaying a flag in support of the terrorist group Hezbollah at one of their gigs.

Before that, there had been calls for festivals to reconsider booking the band over their political stances, and several have done, which prompted artists like Brian Eno, the Mystery Jets and CMAT to sign an open letter accusing Westminster and the British media of a campaign to "remove Kneecap from the public eye".

They put their names to wording that said "in a democracy, no political figures… have the right to dictate who does and does not play at music festivals."

The band have since claimed they're the victims of "political policing" designed to silence their views on Gaza.

So what's the reality like for artists who are outspoken at a time when the world is so divided?

As some of the biggest names in music gathered in London for the Ivors, an annual celebration of songwriting, Self-Esteem - aka Rebecca Lucy Taylor - said the level of scrutiny can be "terrifying".

'The problem with the internet'

She told Sky News: "The problem with the internet is you say one thing, which gets scrutinised, and then you shit yourself, you really do… then you're advised not to. And then you're like 'don't advise me not to!'

"You second-guess anything you want to say any more… but any time I do that, I think 'well that's why you've got to say it then'."

She said it can be frustrating that focus turns on to pop stars' opinions instead of "the people doing the bad things".

Read more:
Why are Kneecap controversial?

'Being a pop artist isn't just about the music'

Former Little Mix singer Jade said: "To be a pop artist these days, it's not just about music, it's: 'What's your political stance?'

"I've always been quite vocal about those things, but in doing so you have even more of a scary spotlight on you, constantly assessing what your thoughts are as a human…it is scary."

Trinidad-born London artist Berwyn, whose songs depict his struggles with UK immigration, says: "Silencing freedom of speech… is a road we don't want to walk down.

"I'm not a politician, this is a very complicated issue, but I do absolutely believe in a human's right to express themselves freely."

But is that freedom of speech dependent on what side you're coming from?

'Unethical investments'

Soon, an event called Mighty Hoopla will take place at Brockwell Park as part of its programme of six festivals this summer.

Artists performing at that are coming under increased pressure from pro-Palestine groups to quit because it's owned by a company called Superstruct, which has links to an American investment firm called KKR.

Critics argue that any KKR-affiliated events should be a red flag to artists as campaigners claim it "invests billions of pounds in companies" that do things like "develop Israeli underground data centres", and they say it has shares in companies that "advertise property on illegally occupied land in the West Bank".