Cantiones Sacrae falls short

The intentions behind this Gesualdo Consort Amsterdam's recording of Sweelinck's score are good, but it's found lacking.

Composer: Sweelinck
Repertoire:  Cantiones Sacrae
Artists: Gesualdo Consort Amsterdam/Harry van der Kamp
Rating:   3/5
Genre: Choral
Label: Glossa GCD 922406


The Music: Sweelinck composed the 37 motets of his Cantiones Sacrae in Calvinist Amsterdam in 1619 – and published them in Catholic Antwerp. All are in five parts at the publisher’s insistence. They are grouped here by genre - Nativity, Psalms, Gospel - where in the original they were mostly random.


The Performance: The Gesualdo Consort of Amsterdam employs one voice to a part, yielding a thin texture. Given that the acoustic is that of a small carpeted room, there is little sense of a rich choral ensemble. Tuning is fine, words discernible, but tone plain. Van der Kamp the bass (he sings and conducts) sounds like a yawn when exposed in Beati pauperes. The soprano pleads dispassionately in O quam beata. Such modesty has a touching effect in the bouncing ‘alleluias’ - like playing leapfrog in cassocks. The motets are interspersed with canons (rounds), which suit well the singers’ modest, grey protestant egalitarianism.


The Verdict: The intention is good, but the result disappointing. Compare this tinsel-less version of the Christmas motet Hodie Christus with the glowing, exuberant throb of the Monteverdi Choir’s (Philips, 462 050). A pity Kamp isn’t truer to his name. The unusual repertoire, however, is a saving grace, as is the informative sleeve note.

Discover Music

Beethoven String Quartet manuscript Classical Music News

From the most expensive manuscripts to the greatest artist interviews, find out the latest music news first here.

What's on from 6am-8pm

From More Music Breakfast at 6am through to Classic FM Drive at 5pm, we play a mix of feel-good classics and upbeat favourites providing the perfect soundtrack to your day.