We got a professional soprano to appraise Lady Gaga’s coloratura at the Super Bowl

8 February 2016, 16:29

gaga national anthem

We asked our very own Catherine Bott to cast a musical ear over Lady Gaga’s performance of the Star Spangled Banner at last night’s Super Bowl.

We could think of no-one better than our very own presenter and soprano with decades of experience, Catherine Bott, to pore over the nuances of Lady Gaga's latest grandstanding performance:

“There’s no doubt about it: Lady Gaga has a powerful, well-produced dramatic soprano voice, and admirable breath control, both of which were essential in the less-than-ideal surroundings of a giant stadium.

Diction, intonation and sense of drama were all exemplary and the microphone – essential for the occasion – was used intelligently. Perhaps there was room for a slightly more restrained approach to embellishment of such an emotive melody – Gaga’s pauses for effect slowed the anthem down too much, sentimentalising it: she was lucky that her piano accompanist was so well-attuned to her spontaneous decorations.

With the emotions reined in a bit and a stricter sense of tempo, this performance of America’s favourite patriotic song could have been even more effective. But she is a sincere and compelling artist.”

Classic FM Apps

Get the Classic FM app for iPhone, iPad and Android - now with HD audio

Musical abbreviations quiz

You won’t get 20/20 on this quiz if you don’t know your musical abbreviations

musician would you rather

This musician edition of Would You Rather is completely excruciating

greatest best man speech

Everyone is saying this pianist gave the greatest best man speech of all time