Why everyone laughing at the FA Cup National Anthem singer is wrong

23 May 2016, 11:36

fa cup national anthem

It’s every singer’s worst nightmare: a huge stage, a television audience and a simple song to sing, but it all goes terribly wrong.

When soprano Karen Harding stood on a podium in the middle of Wembley Stadium, the job seemed simple enough: sing the National Anthem, then naff off stage and let the ball-kicking commence.

Twitter went into an inevitable meltdown as onlookers rushed to be the funniest keyboard warrior:

Which, when you think about it, is pretty cruel. Watching the video back, it’s pretty clear that Harding is fiddling with her earpiece. With a faulty earpiece in, no foldback monitors to guide her, and about 90,000 people shouting at her, it’s inevitable that she wouldn’t hear the band begin the anthem and subsequently miss her cue.

But, the reasonable among you might ask, what about that not-insignificant sound of that 90k-strong crowd singing the anthem right back at her? Why couldn’t she hear it? Unfortunately, when you’re in the middle of that sound, it’s not so simple. That’s why monitor speakers exist. There’s a good chance that, expecting the sound to come through her earpiece, Harding simply wasn’t tuned in to hear the crowd singing the anthem.

Naturally, the feeling of embarrassment for a singer is huge in a situation like this:

But Karen, take it from us: this is not your fault. And if anyone says otherwise, well…

Classic FM Apps

Get the Classic FM app for iPhone, iPad and Android - now with HD audio

Cat composer Alexander Livitsanos

This utterly adorable kitten is the ultimate distraction from work

chocolate bar musical taste

Can we guess your favourite chocolate bar from your favourite composer?

broken e-string violin

This clip captures the sheer horror of an E-string snapping halfway through a live radio broadcast